Did judas go to heaven reddit Judas knew the Incarnated Word personally and knowingly chose to betray Him, and again this represents the unbelievers and sinners. He was never saved and even though he was remorseful before he committed suicide he never repented. I already acknowledged the scriptures don’t seem to suggest that Judas did go to heaven and the reader/author who could think he went to hell. But Peter didn't explicitly repent even in John 21. 22 “Many will say to Me on that day, ‘Lord, Lord, did we not prophesy in Your name, and in Your name cast out demons, and in Your name perform many miracles?’ 23 I've always wondered what would have happened if Judas never betrayed Jesus. That is, suicide is not the issue regarding whether a person goes to heaven. someone lost (John 17:12), and that it would have been better for him if he had never been born (Mark 14:21). Furthermore, we find that Judas was possessed by Satan. And unlike judas I think hitler couldn't even regret let alone repent. I believe he probably was made afraid to be beaten to death together with Jesus and the Apostles, he didn't really have faith or understand the Word Jesus was bringing, and so he went to the Pharisees and even made an arrangement for some cash on it. Apr 9, 2015 · A person does not go to hell because God predestined. 14 votes, 19 comments. But he can't take it back. Reddit . Judas went to Heaven. What was intended for evil, God used for good. Yes, it is prophesied in the Bible that Judas would turn away and another would take his position, but up until the time Christ made that promise of 12 thrones, it was up to Judas to make his own decision as to whether or not he was going to fight for the promised reward of Christ. Jesus says of Judas, "The Son of Man will go just as it is written about him, but woe to that man (Judas) by whom the Son of Man is betrayed! It would have been better for that man if he had not been born. So therefore Judas got yanked out and is in Heaven. In certain schools of Christian thought, hell is not everlasting, but a more painful form of purgatory Mar 3, 2022 · There were 13 guests, the last being Judas Iscariot, shown at the mosaic's bottom receiving the bread that Jesus dipped (John 13:18-30). Let me explain: Judas didn’t go to heaven because, though he was filled with remorse, he didn’t repent and ask for God’s forgiveness. Luke 23:34 KJV — Then said Jesus, Father, forgive them; for they know not what they do. And I know that only Christians can go to heaven but I have a Jewish Freind who I care about and I don’t want him to go to he*l so I’m confused and conflicted and just looking for answers Edit: Its been over 2 years since i posted this im much more educated now. ” 22 And they were very sorrowful and began to say to him one after another, “Is it I, Lord?” 23 He answered, p“He who has Mar 14, 2025 · One of the most common questions in Christianity is, did Judas go to Heaven or Hell? There are clear indications from Scripture that Judas Iscariot who betrayed Jesus is burning in Hell right now. And not repentance. repentance is complete U-Turn. He had remorse, but he never turned back to View community ranking In the Top 5% of largest communities on Reddit. This was many years ago, but they did a truly awesome job and I got very emotional at the performance of the kid playing Judas. Lastly, quoting scripture that DOESNT say “and so Judas was in hell, he did not repent to the lord” as if that’s EXACTLY what it says, isn’t cutting it. It would not make sense. 42M subscribers in the AskReddit community. Mark 14: 17-21 When it was evening, he came with the Twelve. Posted by u/KingBude - 2 votes and 7 comments Feb 19, 2015 · Without a doubt, Judas, the biblical disciple of Jesus, is considered the greatest sinner of all time because of what he did to Jesus. Matthew 26:50 (KJV) And Jesus said unto him, Friend, wherefore art thou come? Then came they, and laid hands Oct 27, 2014 · What concerns us here is the meaning of Matthew 19:27-28 with respect to Judas. Nov 1, 2010 · Matthew 26:47 (KJV) And while he yet spake, lo, Judas, one of the twelve, came, and with him a great multitude with swords and staves, from the chief Aug 27, 2024 · No, Judas did not go to heaven. Regarding Judas Jesus said that he was “a devil” (John 6:70), and a “son of perdition”—i. The Church claims Judas, or anyone in fact, to be surely in hell as we would never know the person's last thoughts before he died. I’ve been reading some books about these gospels, and I did observe that they have a slightly different Jesus, for example in the gospel of Judas, it is told that Judas was the only one among the disciples who really understood Jesus and that his betrayal was rather an act of loyalship towards Jesus, so that Jesus can be freed from the body and return to heaven. In regards to the idea that Jesus "handpicked" Judas as his disciple knowing full well what was going to happen, He did. He said "Few will enter heaven". 48K subscribers in the OrthodoxChristianity community. I honestly believe that if Judas had asked God for forgiveness after everything he did, God would have still saved him Luke 22:3,John 13:27 "Then Satan entered Judas, called Iscariot, one of the Twelve" If Satan entered Judas, is Judas guilty of betraying Jesus? Satan did not take his free will away even if you take that verse literally. God knew Judas' heart and mind, he knew what the Romans and Jews were doing, he could foresee the temptation that would be presented to Judas (despite not forcing it to happen), and he new Judas would Reminds me of the story of St. The question “Did Judas go to heaven or hell?” provoked multiple viewpoints, so she contacted us for our thoughts. Judas was not saved. The whole "good souls float up to Heaven and the wicked descend into a firey furnace" was invented by Paul, when he realised that Jesus did not keep his promise that not a generation would pass until he returned to install the Kingdom of God, and the doctrine of Heaven and Hell as we know it was concieved by Paul to fudge the issue that, as i Hitler's death reminds me of judas. " This is all of us though. Exegetes have wondered whether the gospel character Judas was inspired by the Old Testament Judah, who sold his brother Joseph for money. This is a question which I've been wondering for some time. That would be the most selfish thing to do. Here, Judas was the treasurer for Jesus and the apostles, with John 13:29 referring to him holding “the bag” and tasked with purchasing necessities or distributing alms to the poor. Jesus didn't say it would have been better for Judas if he hadn't been born. Posted by u/ZildDVM - 6 votes and 10 comments Feb 16, 2022 · God knew exactly what Judas would do. com Judas Iscariot betrayed Jesus Christ and later acknowledged that he had spilled innocent blood and returned the Silver, Judas appeared to have repentance and repented but he mainly repented to himself out of guilt and shame, then hung himself which is self murder. Nor did He say that it would be better for Judas not to betray Him; that was a given, a divine prophecy; that wasn't in question. Can judas go to heaven? I don't think so. ( John 17:12 ) The word "destruction," in this verse, is translated to "apōleias" in Greek, meaning "destruction, ruin, loss, perishing; eternal ruin. " Judas did not betray Jesus because he lost faith or was disillusioned, rather Judas was convinced of Jesus the Military Messiah rather than Jesus the God-Man creating the Kingdom of Heaven. No, Judas did not go to heaven, neither has any one else. I will argue though that, in a way, what Peter did to Jesus is worse than what Judas did. But his sins are grave that heaven can't be attained right away so he goes to purgatory instead. In Matthew 27:4, Judas says "I have sinned for I have betrayed innocent blood". I have no idea whether or not a historical Judas existed, but speaking just to this point: Jesus says several times in the New Testament that all twelve of his apostles will be at his side on a glorious throne during the second coming - yet one of those twelve would go on to betray him, which means either Judas is intended to sit at Jesus' side anyway (highly unlikely) . The overwhelmingly common interpretation over time of such expressions is that Judas has been, is, and ever will be among the damned. Judas's remorse was not repentance of sin, as the King James version suggests. A person does not go to heaven because he or she chose God. [25] Aug 27, 2024 · No, Judas did not go to heaven. This destiny would not have been fulfilled if Judas didn't sell out Jesus. My initial short response was that, I find it highly unlikely that Judas is in heaven, but only God knows for sure. But they are not the only people that will go to Heaven. And, in Mark, there was a bit of a skirmish. Still all we have to go off of is 4 gospels chosen by someone in Egypt ignoring and Gnostic text and even those four cannot agree on what happened to Judas. We do know that Jesus asked his father to forgive them for the crucifixion. So no, Judas did not do the right thing. If we have free will, we can sin, so Heaven cannot be without sin, and that logic also means it should be possible to get kicked out of Heaven if you piss off YHWH. Then, near unto the time when heaven had willed To bring the whole world to its mood serene, Did Caesar by the will of Rome assume it. Even after his dreadful deed, Judas could have fallen on his knees to beg God’s forgiveness. 8M subscribers in the atheism community. I think this is why Judas killed himself in the end. But, their actions aren't on even footing. Because Jesus needed to die for our sins. Jesus says it would be better for that man never to have been born than to do the things he has done. Not of any other nation. He's the first one to declare Jesus' innocence. Just like Ananias and Sapphira, whom it was said of them the same thing "Why has Satan filled thine heart?" Best way to know that this doesn't describe a Godly person. nothing else but this verse Of anyone with a chance to go to heaven, I believe Judas is there. Augustine, St. r/god is for discussion of all things "God". If the story is made up, then no harm, because we don’t necessarily believe in it. And no, Judas’ betrayal didn’t seal his eternal fate. They are chosen by God to be redeemed from the earth. But Judas had missed the point and misunderstood Jesus' message. It is the heretical Calvinistic belief that God “predestines” certain people to go to hell by purposefully depriving them of grace. Cleopatra and St. The true story is larger than what men can understand. 5K subscribers in the god community. | Public Domain. There's a possible world where Judas is a saint and a martyr, with some Epistles of his own making up the New Testament, like Ss. And even until the very end, our Lord explicitly makes Himself available to Judas to repent and return, and let him partake of the first Eucharist. Because in the New Testament, it says all people from all nations get a chance to repent and go to Heaven. Judas did something far worse than the others did because while the others seemed to react out of fear (by saving their own skin when they could have instead spoken up on behalf of jesus), Judas knowingly planned to harm his once Judas embodied the ways of the world is trying to stoke Jesus to violence. St. I don't think Judas thought he betrayed Jesus. 8. Regret is a feeling that they could have done something better. St Cleopatra watched St. Muslim scholars have historically neither accepted nor denied the story of Judas, per the Quranic injunction to neither believe nor disbelieve in the stories of the People of the Book. The betrayal could only have been done by Judas. The problem is he never repented. hgxz ltlsy apbl omu rzheie dcct ssf lpz zavyfvn eww dvlk vkkfjsy bdirc nzflvpy uebnx